Facing Marxist Orthodoxy: Western Marxism, The Making, and the Communist Historiographies of Czechoslovakia and Poland, 1948-1990
Abstract
Although the impact of Thompson's work outside the UK has been recognized and pointed to many times, the ways in which Thompsonian categories and concepts, or Marxist thought from the West more broadly, was received in the countries of the former Eastern Bloc remain rather unclear. Although The Making has never been translated into Polish, Czech, or Slovak, the historians of East-Central European countries were not totally cut off from Western scholarship.
Major academic institutes and universities throughout the communist bloc maintained basic contacts with colleagues in the West, and Thompson's work was known among some local social historians. Marxism from the West in general and Thompson's work in particular posed challenges that had to be dealt with.
This paper traces the ways in which historians of Poland and Czechoslovakia responded to these challenges to the official position of Marxist orthodoxy. Taking The Making as an example, it highlights the reception (or lack thereof) of Western influences on local scholarship, and the dynamics of these encounters - whether they were affirmative or critical - in relation to the changing political landscape of East-Central European countries after World War II.