Abstrakt
Faik Kurtulmuş's exploration of the epistemic basic structure (EBS) invites us to think about the generation, dissemination, and absorption of knowledge in a society, emphasizing the role of institutions in determining epistemic outcomes. Moreover, Kurtulmuş-in joint work with Gürol Irzık-offers a normative take on the EBS from the viewpoint of the theory of justice and does not shy away from drawing specific policy recommendations.
Thus, a powerful, innovative concept is used to extend an influential theory and draw out its practical implications. What more is there to wish for? A project of such ambition inevitably faces serious challenges.
I address the issue of the alignment between the ideal and non-ideal elements of Kurtulmuş's theory with an eye toward the practicalities of social reform. My central claim is that the philosophers striving to promote distributive epistemic justice need to think carefully about whom they intend to address with their proposals and how to persuade such addressees.
I also maintain that emphasis on a holistic approach to social reform represents a major hindrance to its pragmatic success.